We run our website the way we wished the whole internet worked: we provide high quality original content with no ads. We are funded solely by your direct support. Please consider supporting this project.

Your Spiritual “Say-So”

Families & People

Single mothers in prayer at Nazareth House in Manila, capital of the Philippines. | Wodu Media

In yesterday’s post, I summarized what Jesus and the rest of the Bible says about prayer. For many, that is enough. “God said it, I believe it, that settles it for me.” But for others, like myself, the practice of petitionary prayer raises a number of theological questions that need to be answered.

The trouble is that, at first glance, trying to impact God and change the world through prayer doesn’t seem to make any theological sense. I used to struggle with this a lot. I’d be praying and all of a sudden wonder, “Why am I doing this?” Yes, I was obeying God. But what was I actually accomplishing, I wondered? Am I trying to twist God’s arm to get him to do something he doesn’t already want to do, like a child stubbornly pestering a parent to give him a new toy? That surely couldn’t be right. If God didn’t already want to do what I was asking him to do, then what I’m asking him to do clearly isn’t the best thing to do, since if it were, the all-good God would already want to do it.

On the other hand, if I’m asking God to do something he already wants to do, then I again have to wonder what I’m accomplishing by asking him to do it. If God wants to do something because it’s the best thing to do, it seems he would do it whether I pray or not, since God is all-good and always does what is best.

So whether I’m praying about something God wants to do or doesn’t want to do, it seems my prayer is useless. It seems I’m engaging in a nonsensical, pro forma activity.

I suspect it’s reasoning like this that leads many to adopt the cliché that prayer is for our sake, not Gods. Given that God is all-powerful, all-good and all-wise, folks simply can’t fathom any other purpose that prayer could possibly serve.

Yet, since this is clearly an unbiblical position, we need an alterative way of understanding prayer. The questions I’m going to try to answer are a) What possible difference can prayer make to an all-good and all-powerful God?, and b) Why would an all-wise God leverage so much of his will being done on earth on whether or not his people talk to him?

My questions began to be resolved years ago when I began to think about prayer in light of God’s purpose for creation. God created humans to be his viceroys on the earth. We were placed here to administrate God’s loving providence “on earth as it is in heaven.” Out of the fullness of life we get from our relationship with God, we were to reflect God’s loving character and purpose to each other, the animals and the earth. He gave us “say-so” over this domain, with the goal that we would lovingly choose to align our “say-so” with his “say-so” so that his loving “say-so” would reign on the earth through us. We were to be co-laborers with God and co-rulers with Christ (2 Tim. 2:12; Rev. 5:10, 20:6), thus ensuring that the earth would be the domain of God’s reign — the Kingdom of God.

Now, we all know we have “say-so” on a physical level. Our ideas, words and bodily activity impacts others and affects what comes to pass, for better or for worse. But what the Bible’s teaching on prayer reveals is that this isn’t our only – or even our primary – “say-so.” We also have a “say-so” to impact God and affect what comes to pass on a spiritual level, and this “say-so” is activated when we communicate with God.

In this light, it’s really no more difficult to understand why God would to some extent leverage his will being done “on earth as it is in heaven” on prayer than it is to understand why God would to some extent leverage anything on our choice to use our physical ‘say-so” in various ways. If God wants a world that is capable of sharing in and reflecting his love, he must populate it with free agents who have their own “say-so” – and to this extent the accomplishing of his “say-so” on earth must depend on how we freely choose to use our “say-so.”

Everything about God’s purpose for creation is centered on our choosing to enter into a loving relationship with him. Relationships are all about communication. We relate to others only as we communicate ourselves in a variety of ways to them and they communicate themselves to us. Relationships and communication are two sides of the same coin.

So, if the central goal of creation is a relationship with God that empowers humans to be God’s viceroys on the earth, it makes sense that God would design the world such that communicating with him would be a central means by which we carry out our viceroy duties. While it violates the common sense of our carnal minds to trust in prayer, if you think about the matter in terms of God’s purpose for creation, it makes sense that the most important exercise of our “say-so” would be bound up with our communication with God.

Related Reading

Podcast: Dear Greg: My Friend Committed Suicide. Should I Pray for Her Soul?

When does our story end? Greg talks about suicide and praying for the dead.   http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0414.mp3

What is the Kingdom of God (Part 1)

We all know what the Kingdom of God is, right? But this is precisely the problem. Since we are all to a large extent products of our culture, what seems obviously true and right to us will be at least influenced, if not determined, by what seems obviously true and right to our culture. This,…

What the hell are we doing here?

Meet Collin Simula. He lives in Columbus, Ohio, and is a part of Central Vineyard church. He is a 30-year-old graphic designer, and a happily married father of three. Collin has spent his whole life in the Church, in every denomination imaginable, from Calvinist/Christian Reformed churches, to a Baptist high school, being a part of…

Does the Bible forbid interracial marriages?

Absolutely not! Racist Christians used to argue against interracial marriage by quoting Old Testament passages that prohibited Jews from marrying non-Jews. This prohibition had nothing to do with race, however. In fact, there was no concept of different “races” until white Europeans invented it during the Colonial period, partly to justify their enslavement of other…

Sermon Clip: Hunger Games

To begin the series on emotional intelligence and the roles this plays in our relationships, Greg Boyd introduces the foundational teaching of the entire series. Here’s a hint, it’s LOVE. In the full sermon, Greg takes a look at the role Jesus plays in our relationships and the importance of letting Christ be the source…

The Easiest (and Hardest) Spiritual Discipline

The glory of God surrounds you every second of every day. What a profound truth! But most of the time—like a dark cloud blocking the sun—the mental chatter about the past and the future keeps us from seeing it. We are absorbed in the past—with all the regrets and pain—or the future—shaped by both hopes…