We run our website the way we wished the whole internet worked: we provide high quality original content with no ads. We are funded solely by your direct support. Please consider supporting this project.

Why Did God Heal or Not?
In 1996 a 27-year-old man in my church named David was diagnosed with an inoperable brain cancer. The doctors decided to send David to the Mayo Clinic to receive some experimental treatments on the slim hope these might at least prolong his life. The night before David left, I and a dozen other people went over to his house to pray. For over two hours we engaged in fervent warfare prayer on his behalf, revolting in Jesus’s name against the cancer and anything in the spirit realm that might be involved in it.
Two days later I received an elated call from David. The doctors at the Mayo Clinic could not find any trace of cancer!
Of course, the mayo clinic staff insisted that David’s local doctors must have misread his brain scans, but his local doctor said this wasn’t possible. The mystery was never resolved, which was fine with us. We just praised God that he was set free from a life-threatening infirmity that ultimately is traceable back to Satan’s oppressive regime.
But we must be honest. As impressive as this event was, it’s possible nothing supernatural occurred. Despite their insistence to the contrary, David’s doctors may have misread his brain scans, and it’s possible David’s cancer went into “spontaneous remission.” But these seem very unlikely. And since I have good reason for believing Jesus is the son of God and that his followers are supposed to be able to affect things through the power of prayer, I feel justified calling David’s healing miracle.
Now, in the interest of full disclosure, and to illustrate how arbitrary life sometimes this, I’m compelled to add the sad fact that three years after his miraculous healing, David’s brain cancer returned. And this time he wasn’t healed.
I admit that this is theologically disturbing. But I don’t think this invalidates the miracle. For all we know, Lazarus may have died three years after Jesus raised him from the dead, perhaps from the very disease that killed him the first time (John 11:1–46). All healings this side of heaven are temporary signs of the coming age when all forms of infirmity will be permanently overcome. Until the kingdom comes in its fullness, we will all eventually die. The very last enemy that will be overcome is death (1 Cor 15). So David’s death doesn’t undermine the genuineness of the healing.
But it does illustrate how mysterious and seemingly arbitrary life is. Why was healing prayer effective in one instance but not in another, when we were revolting against the same illness in the same person? It’s impossible to say. Yet, as I said in yesterday’s post, it’s important we understand why we can’t understand this. It’s not because God’s will or character is so mysterious. It’s rather because we live in an unfathomably complex creation.
We don’t need to blame the arbitrariness of life on God. Nor do we need to try to explain away this arbitrariness by claiming some people have sufficient faith while others don’t. We simply need to respect the impenetrable ambiguity of an unfathomably complex creation and confess, as finite human beings, that “we don’t know.”
Image by mathrock via Flickr
Category: Q&A
Tags: Faith, healing, Sickness, Spiritual Warfare, Warfare Worldview
Topics: Faith & Doubt, The Problem of Evil
Related Reading

The Nature of Human Rebellion
God placed Adam in the Garden and instructed him to “protect” it (Gen. 2:15). The word is often translated “till” or “keep,” implying that Adam’s main responsibility was to protect the pristine Garden from weeds. This is certainly a possible interpretation of this word, but in light of the cunning serpent that shows up in…

The Reality of Satan and the Spiritual Realm
A theme that underlies Jesus’ entire ministry is the apocalyptic assumption that creation has been seized by a cosmic force and that God is now battling this force to rescue it. Jesus understood himself to be the one in whom this battle was to be played out in a decisive way. The assumption is evident…

The Benefit of the Doubt
In my last two posts (here and here) I’ve given five arguments against the common way Evangelical Christians tend to think about faith. More specifically, I’m calling into question the assumption that a person’s faith is as strong as they are free of doubt. I’ll conclude this line of questioning today by offering four other…

Sermon Clip: God In The Gallows
Greg has recently returned from a three week trip in Europe, and today he shares stories of how the Kingdom message of a Jesus-looking God, radical love and non-violence is truly spreading all over the world. You can view the full sermon here: http://whchurch.org/sermons-media/sermon/god-in-the-gallows

War in the Heavens!
What does spiritual warfare look like from the perspective of the physical world? Our friend David D. Flowers speculated on that question in a post he entitled Dark Matter vs Dark Energy: War in the Heavens. Referencing Greg’s Satan and the Problem of Evil, David considers the possibility that the interaction between dark matter and dark energy that…

Does God Intervene?
The Open View of the future recognizes the vast influence of all the angelic and human wills God created, which, in turn, influences the various outcomes and circumstances in life. Therefore life is arbitrary because of the way the decisions made by an unfathomably vast multitude of free agents intersect with each other. How life…