We run our website the way we wished the whole internet worked: we provide high quality original content with no ads. We are funded solely by your direct support. Please consider supporting this project.

Following Jesus Doesn’t Work

I met a middle aged woman one day who told me she had given up on Christianity. “It just didn’t work for me,” she said. My response was: “What on earth made you think Jesus was supposed to work for you? The truth is that you were supposed to work for him.”

The sentiment is widespread. I seems that many assume Jesus is supposed to be our personal magical genie who grants our wishes, at least some of the time. Such a magical view of faith is catastrophic, for people abandon what they thought was the Christian faith when it doesn’t work. And worse, people think they’re embracing the Christian faith when it does.

Nothing in the Bible suggests obeying God is supposed to “work for us.” According to the biblical pattern, more often than not following God made things worse for people, not better.

Consider, for example, Mary, the mother of Jesus. She was just a young teenager when the angel Gabriel appeared to her saying:

Greetings, favored one! The Lord is with you….you will conceive in your womb and bear a son, and you will name him Jesus. He will be great, and will be called the Son of the Most High, and the Lord God will give to him the throne of his ancestor David. He will reign over the house of Jacob forever, and of his kingdom there will be no end (Luke 1:28-33).

To miraculous conceive, give birth to, and raise the Christ-child – what an honor! Mary undoubtedly felt highly “favored.” Thirty years later, however, Mary didn’t feel so “favored.” She actually thought her son had gone stark mad. He was making outlandish if not blasphemous claims. He was arrogantly confronting religious authorities. He was hanging out with social rejects and inviting trouble makers (zealots) into his inner circle. He was gaining a reputation for being insane if not demon possessed – to say nothing of being a glutton and a drunkard. And, consequently, several attempts had already been made on his life. So she and her other children when out to “restrain him” (Mark 3:21). It didn’t work.

Not long after this, the thing Mary feared happened. Jesus was murdered. The angel long ago hadn’t said anything about this. Mary had to watch her son, the one she was supposedly “favored” to bear, die an excruciating, humiliating death by crucifixion. What happened to the promise that Jesus was going to be “great,” “the Son of the Most High,” an heir of the “throne of his ancestor David”?

Imagine her heartbreak and confusion. We sometimes soften this by jumping ahead to Jesus’ resurrection. But we need to appreciate that neither Mary nor any of the disciples at this point understood Jesus’ talk of a resurrection. It was so contrary to their ordinary way of thinking that it simply didn’t register. This horrific moment was the end as far as Mary was concerned. This horror was her great reward for submitting to God.

Something similar is true for most of God’s heroes. John the Baptist spent the last year of his life in a lonely prison. He knew that the messiah foretold in the Old Testament was supposed to “proclaim liberty to the captives, and release to the prisoners” (Is 61:1). And so he sent messengers to Jesus asking him, “Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?”( Matt 11:2). In his desperate situation, John was doubting. Was Jesus really the messiah, and was his entire life, spent in a harsh desert preparing the way for Jesus as the Messiah, a wasted life?

Jesus responded by referring back to the Isaiah prophecy, telling John’s messengers to report what they saw. “[T]he blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news brought to them” (Matt 11:3-5). But Jesus left out the part about the release of prisoners! No wonder Jesus immediately added, “blessed is anyone who takes no offense at me.” (Matt. 11:6.)

Jesus was in effect saying, “Yes, John, I am the hoped for Messiah. I’m doing all the things the Messiah is supposed to do – except the one thing you need him to do.” No explanation; just a denial.

John would soon be decapitated as a sort of party joke for Herod’s vicious wife. John had forsaken everything to do the Lord’s work and this is what he got for it. The Messiah inexplicably leaves him to rot and suffer an ignoble death in prison.

Moses suffered an equally cruel fate. For 40 years he battled frustration working with a whiney people walking through a mostly barren wilderness. He never wanted the job and in fact tried hard to get out of it, yet here he was. The one thing that kept him going was the promise of a land flowing with milk and honey. And then, just as they are about to enter into the promised land, the Lord tells Moses,

…ascend this mountain of the Abraham … and view the land of Canaan, which I am giving to the Israelites for a possession; and you shall die there on the mountain…. Although you may view the land from a distance, you shall not enter it – the land that I am giving to the Israelites.” (Deut 32:49, 52).

This isn’t the “happy ever after” ending we want or expect for our heroes today. It frankly seems a bit cruel. Moses gets to look at the land he’s not allowed to enter – all because of a mistake he made decades earlier. His grand prize for sacrificing everything in obedience to Yahweh is a longing gaze from a distance and then death.

And so it is, in one form or another, for most of the heroes of the Bible. Yes there were blessings and even occasional miracles sprinkled throughout some of the heroes’ lives. But more often than not their obedience resulted in pain, sadness and disappointment. Most “died in faith without having received the promises” (Heb 11:13). Some were “tortured….suffered mocking and flogging, and even chains and imprisonment.” Others were “stoned to death,” “sawn in two,” “killed by the sword” and “went about in skins of sheep and goats, destitute, persecuted, tormented”(Heb 11: 35-38). The moral of the story seems to be that if you’re looking to make your life better, here and now, don’t listen to God!

Such is the biblical pattern, and its certainly exemplified in the life and death of Jesus. In anguish he asks the Father if its possible to accomplish their objective another way, but there is not. His obedience to the Father leads him to be scourged, mocked and crucified. And Jesus tells us that, if this is what happens to the master, the servants must expect the same. If its benefits in the here and now you’re looking for, do not follow Jesus. Indeed, if its benefits your looking for, you cannot follow Jesus.

To follow Jesus and enter into Kingdom life, we must be willing to go through what Jesus went through as well as what  Mary, John, Moses and many other heroes of the faith went through. If we do not actually have to endure suffering, that is simply good fortune, not because we are specially “blessed.” To follow Jesus authentically is to die to everything the flesh-self holds dear, whether we actually loose them or not. We must die to the quest to avoid of pain and inconvenience; die to the quest for pleasure, power and fame; die to the security of our homes, family, friends and nation; and even die to the certainty of our opinions. Every attempt to gain a personal sense of worth, significance and  security by what we do, what we accomplish, what we acquire and who we impress must die.

Jesus commands this much, not because he is mean, but because he is more profoundly in love with us than we could possibly ever imagine. And he knows that it is this false, self-centered way of living that is keeping us from true life. When we have truly died, we discover this. To be free from the self that is addicted to the question: What’s in it for me? is to be truly ALIVE and free. It is to enter into the kingdom of God.

But, as Jesus always taught, you can only find this life if you complete loose your life.

If you’re focusing on this life, here and now, following Jesus doesn’t “work” and we should stop telling people that it does. But if we’ll die to the attempt to make things “work” for us, we’ll discover a deeper LIFE that no longer cares about what  does and doesn’t work for us.  We’ll discover the LIFE of the Kingdom.

Related Reading

Racism: Why Whites have Trouble “Getting It”

I’m a member of a special task group on racial reconciliation that consists of a dozen or so pastors from around the Twin Cities. We’ve been meeting periodically for the past year or so in order to strategize how to help the Church of the Twin Cities as a whole move forward in racial reconciliation.…

Does the Old Testament Justify “Just War”?

Since the time of Augustine, Christians have consistently appealed to the violent strand of the Old Testament to justify waging wars when they believed their cause was “just.” (This is Augustine’s famous “just war” theory.) Two things may be said about this. First, the appeal to the OT to justify Christians fighting in “just” wars…

Vacationing in a War Zone

Suppose a family decided to go on vacation to a nice cabin on a beautiful shore in a distant country. This vacationing family naturally wanted to tune out the problems of the world, indulge themselves, relax and enjoy life and each other as much as possible. This is simply what families do on vacation. Now…

Why is America Becoming More Politically Divided?

I watched a 20/20 special the other night on politics in America. The show explored the “growing political divide” in our country. Here’s some of the information found in this program. * Since the early 70’s Americans have become increasing polarized in their political views. Communities that once were pretty evenly split politically are now…

God’s Goal for the World

 Helga Weber via Compfight In a world that is all about doom and gloom… In a time when we never seem to have enough… In the midst of messages that tell us that we don’t measure up… In an age when we are more interested in whether or not we can own automatic weapons than…


Here’s something to inspire you on this Sunday morning. Image by Megan Allen. Sourced via Flickr.