Myth of a Christian Religion Endorsements and Reviews
Imitating the life of Jesus isn’t solely about embracing his message of love, sacrifice and service, according to evangelical pastor Boyd. In his latest book, the author of The Myth of a Christian Nation also asserts that becoming part of the “beautiful revolution” means rebelling against everything that is incompatible with that way of life, including violence, poverty, sexual promiscuity and secularism. While exhortations to practice the presence of God and generous to the poor are likely to be uncontroversial, the writer seems to enjoy afflicting the comfortable, whether they are church-going believers or secular atheists. His critique of the “pagan values of our nation” and his impassioned call to choose love over judgment may occasion heated conversation among more conservative readers, while his endearing honesty and accessible style will undoubtedly appeal to others. Boyd has included an extensive action guide, whicj includes multiple exercises for self-reflection, as well as his practical suggestions for churches and small groups on how, as he sees it, to lose one’s religion and become a part of the radical kingdom of Jesus.
Greg Boyd’s latest book, “The Myth of a Christian Religion” (subtitled “Losing Your Religion for the Beauty of a Revolution”), is a bona fide paradigm shifter. Boyd is an Evangelical, to be sure, but definitely not the run-of-the-mill, cookie-cutter kind, as he demonstrated in earlier works: “The Myth of a Christian Nation,” “God of the Possible,” and “Is God to Blame?” Dr. Boyd is, in fact, an Evangelical theologian, pastor, and award-winning author whose book, “The Jesus Legend,” co-written with Paul Eddy, won the 2008 Christianity Today Book of the Year Award in the Biblical Studies category.
So, what is this “revolution” Boyd is talking about? Up front, he confesses to being a skeptic, not of faith or scripture, but he is skeptical of the worth of modern American Christianity. As a graduate student he grew increasingly aware of “how central following the example of Jesus is to the understanding of what it means to ‘be saved.’” He writes, “This slowly opened my eyes to the radical contradiction between the lifestyle Jesus calls his followers to embrace, on the one hand, and the typical American lifestyle on the other. It struck me that the Church in America largely shares—even celebrates—the typical American lifestyle.” His conclusions are validated by research showing that the values of American Evangelical churchgoers are largely indistinguishable from those of non-churchgoing Americans. This disturbed Boyd and led him to wonder how such a thing could possibly be. His conclusions are the crux of “The Myth of a Christian Religion” in which he contends that American Christians need a backward “revolution” away from the pervading popular culture and back to the lifestyle Jesus taught and demonstrated in the Gospels, a view summed up in a single biblical passage that states, “Whoever claims to live in him must live as Jesus did.” That’s a tall order. But it is the patent teaching of scripture.
Boyd’s contention is that centuries of dogma and religion have made modern Christianity very dissimilar to and incompatible with what Jesus lived and taught. He tackles this thesis on several fronts, devoting a chapter to each, saying that to be true followers of the Jesus of the Gospels we need a ruthless revolution (some might call it a revival) against the modern idolatries of secularism, nationalism, religion, judgmentalism, individualism, violence, social oppression, racism, greed, ecological abuse, and sexual exploitation. Perhaps the most striking chapters for me were the ones attacking Christian “Nationalism” and “Violence,” chapters which include a reproduction of Lars Justinen’s controversial painting depicting Jesus washing the feet of Osama Bin Laden.
Boyd himself is somewhat of a controversial figure among Evangelicals. While he deplores activists who masquerade right-wing politics behind a flimsy cloak of Christianity and is a leading voice of open theism (the view that the future is open and therefore known to God more as a realm of possibilities than certainties), he is also a vocal critic of the radical scholarship of the “Jesus Seminar” and of liberal New Testament scholars like John Dominic Crossan and Burton Mack. Obvciously, Greg Boyd is a person unafraid to hold and advance unconvential viewpoints, but by standing between these opposing camps he is sure to draw fire from both sides.
-Jim Miller, Book Review for Busy Pastors
The Myth of a Christian Religion is one of the most sensible, fog-clearing books that I’ve read on the subject God’s Kingdom to date. I highly recommend it to all Christians, especially those who wish to cut through the religious clutter that surrounds American politics today.
– Frank Viola, author of From Eternity to Here, Reimagining Church, and Pagan Christianity
Greg Boyd is doing the prophetic work of exposing the false gods and idols of our age, debunking the militant “christianity” of crusades and “holy” wars, the triumphalist evangelicalism of moral gate-keeping and mean finger-pointing, the prosperity “gospel” of the American dream and manifest destiny… so that we can rediscover the true Gospel of our Lover Jesus that casts the mighty from their thrones and lifts up the lowly.
– Shane Claiborne, www.thesimpleway.org
Assessing Jordan Peterson’s 12 Rules for Life by Greg Boyd “We eternally inhabit order, surrounded by chaos. We eternally occupy known territory, surrounded by the unknown.” Nowhere in 12 Rules of Life (or anywhere else that I know of) does Peterson bring together the various aspects of his multifaceted philosophy to demonstrate how they form…
Assessing Jordan Peterson’s 12 Rules for Life by Greg Boyd In my previous two posts (post 8 & post 9) I critically evaluated Peterson’s thinking on hierarchies, race and white privilege. In this post I’ll address three other aspects of Peterson’s thought that was outlined in post 5, post 6, and post 7. On the…
Assessing Jordan Peterson’s 12 Rules for Life by Greg Boyd As we saw earlier in this series (see: post 7), Peterson argues that social hierarchies among humans are as natural as they are among lobsters and every other species of animal on the planet. Whenever there is anything worth doing, anything of value, some people…
Do you have a friend who’s got questions about God? Greg’s father was an atheist who had lots of questions. Over an extended period, Greg and his father wrote letters to one another where they talked honestly about them. The questions include: Why is the world so full of suffering? Why does God create earthquakes…
Assessing Jordan Peterson’s 12 Rules of Life “There is a powerful call to proper Being in the story of the third temptation [of Jesus]. To obtain the greatest possible prize—the establishment of the Kingdom of God on Earth, the resurrection of Paradise – the individual must conduct his or her life in a manner that requires…
Greg and Thomas talk about Open Theism and how Greg’s views differ from Thomas’s. Theology nerds, get your compass and your flashlight and prepare to go DEEEEEP in the weeds! Thomas’s book: God Can’t Episode 487 http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0487.mp3