Is Longing for Justice Inconsistent with Love? A Response to Paul Copan (#3)
In a paper delivered at the Evangelical Theological Society in November, Paul Copan spent a good amount of time arguing that aspects of the NT conflict with the understanding of love that I espouse in Crucifixion of the Warrior God (CWG).
For example, Copan cites the parable Jesus told in Luke 18:1-8 about a widow who wouldn’t leave a certain unjust judge alone until he heard her case, because she wanted justice against her opponent. Similarly, Copan cites Revelation 6:9-10 which depicts martyrs crying out to God, asking him, “how long will it be before you judge and avenge our blood on the inhabitants of the earth?” And in Revelation 18:20 the saints are told to rejoice because God has judged Babylon. Copan argues that this longing to see wrongdoers punished and this rejoicing when they are judged is inconsistent with the view of love I espouse in CWG.
In response, I don’t see how the longing for justice to be done in the face of evil conflicts with anything I say in CWG. Indeed, I think the moral center of every morally healthy human being longs for the moral scales of the universe to be balanced. The thought that those who inflict suffering on innocent people would never have to answer for it grates on our internal moral compass. This is what leads most people to feel that violence against wrongdoers is justified. Yet, Paul tells disciples of Jesus that we are to never repay evil with evil by taking justice into our own hands and retaliating. We are to instead leave all vengeance to God (Rom 12:17-19). Trusting that the Judge of the earth will right every wrong in the end, we are to surrender to God our impulse to carry out justice on our own. The material Copan cites simply expresses the longing for God to carry this out, and it conflicts with nothing I said in CWG.
One more very important point needs to be made, however. The longing to see justice done becomes vindictive and ungodly if it is not accompanied by an even more profound longing to see wrongdoers repent, receive forgiveness, and be transformed by the love of God into the likeness of Christ. Paul teaches that love believes the best and hopes for the best for everyone (Rom 13:7), and we are called to follow Jesus’ example when he prayed for the forgiveness of those who crucified him (Lk 23:34). This longing for the forgiveness and transformation of those who perpetrate evil doesn’t conflict with our innate longing to see justice done. It simply reflects the more profound hope of love that the judgment of evil doers wouldn’t be necessary.
But if love leads us to hope that judgment will be unnecessary, should we not be saddened when it is necessary? So how can the saints in Revelation be told to rejoice over the judgment that is falling on Babylon?
The answer is that throughout Revelation, Babylon symbolizes the political wing of Satan’s regime. It represents all the kingdoms of the world that are under the deception of the Beast and that therefore trust in military power rather than in the power of self-sacrificial love as embodied in the slain lamb and its followers. The saints in Revelation are thus not rejoicing over any actual human beings coming under judgment; they are rejoicing because the power-hungry way of trying to rule the world, which has caused such massive violence and suffering throughout history, has finally self-destructed. And this self-destruction is the just judgment of God.
Photo on VisualHunt
Greg considers: “Who actually killed Ananias and Sapphira.” This ancient murder mystery has enormous theological implications! Listen as Inspector Boyd hunts for clues and builds a most compelling case. http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0108.mp3 Photo credit: jean louis mazieres via VisualHunt.com / CC BY-NC-SA
In the previous blog I argued that God is cross-like love. In this blog I’d like to take this a step further by demonstrating why the cross alone could function as the definitive revelation of God’s true character and by showing how this revelation weaves together everything Jesus was about. If you want to know…
In this short sermon clip, Greg Boyd discusses how Christians should react to the world with love. In the Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve were tempted to eat from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. They did this because they didn’t understand that God was protecting them. In this sermon, Greg…
Greg gives some updates on Crucifixion of the Warrior God, and prays for Jesus to delay his return. http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0124.mp3
We were created for unbroken, loving fellowship with God. We see this in the creation story. As we share in this unbroken, trusting fellowship with God, we participate in the very love that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit share throughout eternity. We also read in the creation story that sin ruptured this fellowship and sidetracked…
In his critique of Crucifixion of the Warrior God (CWG), Paul Copan makes a concerted effort to argue that the God revealed in Jesus Christ and witnessed to throughout the NT is not altogether non-violent. One of the passages Copan cites against me is the famous account of Ananias and Sapphira falling down dead immediately…