mystery

4 Reasons to Believe in a Spiritual Realm

For the last century, a large number of theologians and church leaders have claimed that the biblical view of spiritual warfare—where there is an actual realm where angels and demons exist—is no longer believable. The influential German scholar, Rudolf Bultmann famously wrote, “It is impossible to use electric light and the wireless and to avail ourselves of modern medical and surgical discoveries, and at the same time to believe in the New Testament world of spirits and miracles” (New Testament and Mythology, 5).

Many scholars continue to make this claim. The famous Catholic scholar, Hans Kung suggests that belief in Satan and demons are a piece of “outdated medieval thought” and when believed by Christians it “throws away all credibility for theology and the church” (On Being Christian, 369). Some even argue that if we believe in such things as demons and angels, then we must embrace all of the Bible’s pre-scientific cosmology, including things like a flat earth and a six thousand year old creation.

While there is no denying that there is a mythical element to the various conceptions of spirit agents in Scripture, we have to think about what it means to embrace the biblical view of spiritual warfare in a scientific age. We obviously cannot be asked to conceive of an evil cosmic agent along the lines of a many-headed sea monster (Ps 74:14) or angels riding in chariots of fire (2 Kings 6:17). It’s one thing to grant that the way someone conceived of a cosmic agent was mythic and quite a different thing to claim the very idea of cosmic spirits is mythic. All of our conceptions of spirit agents—including God—are mythic inasmuch as these agents are nonphysical. The important question, therefore, is not whether biblical depictions of angels, demons, and the powers are mythic, but whether these mythic portrayals point to actual entities.

Here I would like to offer four observations that supports the existence of a spiritual reality:

  1. While we have compelling grounds for believing that the cosmology of the Bible was scientifically incorrect, we have no similar grounds for concluding that biblical depictions of spirits was mistaken. To illustrate this point, one could remove the prescientific cosmology from the Bible, and nothing pertaining to its central story line and message would be lost. If one were to extract all references to spirit agents, however, the entire narrative would become unraveled.
  2. The only way to find no place for things like spirits and miracles is to assume at the outset that natural law as described by science provides an exhaustive account of reality. The vast majority of modern Western people have no difficulty believing in spirits and miracles while also continuing to believe in science and use modern technology. Most today do not share the metaphysical assumption that naturalistic science must explain all things.
  3. “Critical scholars” whose naturalistic perspective discounts biblical depictions of spirits and miracles, are in fact being uncritical as they have difficulty turning the same critical eye to discern the arbitrariness of their own assumptions. They presuppose the superiority of their cultural perspective over that of other cultures and they tend to be elitist as they presume that the masses who believe in things like spirits lack the intellectual acuity to perceive what they see. In other words, these so-called “critical scholars” are not self-critical.
  4. Reports of something like “demon possession” and “exorcism” can be found in most cultures and religions throughout history. It is interesting how much in common they have with the reports of the New Testament, despite the vast differences in cultures and belief systems in which they are found. What’s most intriguing is that increasing numbers of anthropologists, ethnographers, sociologists and psychologists are reporting their own firsthand experiences with the “supernatural” while acknowledging the inadequacy of natural explanations.

While we Western Christians may find it challenging to make theological sense of spiritual experiences, whatever else we make of them, they provide empirical support for the NT view that such a spiritual realm is real. The claim that modern Westerners can no longer believe in such things was never warranted or accurate, but in light of the demise of dogmatic naturalism, which tries to comprehensively explain everything through the laws of science, its fallaciousness is now more apparent than ever.

—Adapted from Understanding Spiritual Warfare, pages 129-147

Photo credit: Dustin Scarpitti

Related Reading

On Obedience as Spiritual Warfare (podcast)

In this episode Greg talks about the role of obedience in Spiritual Warfare. Episode 33 http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0033.mp3

When to Do Spiritual Warfare

If the world is engulfed in spiritual warfare, how do we know when we’re confronting a demon that requires deliverance prayer, or simply confronting a “natural” by-product of the fallen world that requires medical or therapeutic attention?  A few years ago, a man from my church called me saying that he had been attacked by…

That Weird Episode with the Pigs

In my opinion, the single strangest episode recounted in the Gospels is the account of Jesus’ encounter with a demonized man that ended with two thousand pigs drowning themselves in the Sea of Galilee (Mk 5:1-10//Mt 8:28-34; Lk 8:26-39). Some find it morally objectionable that this mass suicide was the result of Jesus allowing the…

Terror in the Night

I’ll never forget the night it first happened to me. I was thirteen, sharing a bedroom with my older brother. I woke up in the middle of the night and felt as if something was pinning me to the bed, choking me, and electrocuting me, all at the same time.   The wind was blowing through…

Evil, St. Augustine, & the “Secret” Higher Harmony

The problem of evil constitutes the single most difficult challenge to Christian theism. Volumes upon volumes have been written with the express purpose of rationally reconciling the belief in an all-good and all-powerful God with the reality that life is frequently an inescapable nightmare. Indeed, it is not overstating the case to claim that no…

What’s Wrong With The World?

 Hartwig HKD via Compfight The reports coming out of Fort Hood this morning once again highlight that our world is messed up. And it often feels like we are rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic as we try to find answers to address the problems we face. Here are some reflections by Greg on…