We run our website the way we wished the whole internet worked: we provide high quality original content with no ads. We are funded solely by your direct support. Please consider supporting this project.

light mystery

The Universal Experience of the “Spiritual”

Humans have from prehistoric times generally assumed the reality of spir­its who transcend our physical existence. Outside of post-Enlightenment western intellectual culture the belief in spirits is almost universal. Whether conceptualized as spirits of nature or as power animals (as in pri­mordial cultures), as helpful malã’ika or malicious Jinn (Islam) or as guardian angels or sinister demons (in Christianity), a belief in the reality of good and evil spirits has been one of the most pervasive commonalties of human culture throughout history.

Most frequently, and certainly in its most ancient forms, the belief in spir­its was combined with a belief in a highest god, and many times with a belief in a single Creator. Moreover, there has almost always been an awareness that these spirits can influence human affairs, for better or for worse, and that there is on some level conflict among these spirits which affects human life. In short, most cultures throughout history have in one form or another embraced some version of the warfare worldview.

It is difficult to adequately account for the universality of this belief and the remarkable commonalties which are found amidst otherwise disparate cultures regarding the contents of this belief unless we suppose that these different cultures are intuiting and experiencing something real. This doesn’t of course prove that the spirits are real. But it does show that, bar­ring any convincing evidence to the contrary, the belief that spirits are real is rational, the protestations of secularized western academics not with­standing.

Indeed, in most cultures this belief in spirits has not only been something people held to but something they experienced. In addition, we must take into account the fact that throughout history and continuing on in our day many people have experienced what they interpret to be a spirit presence. Such experiences are not limited to any particular culture or any particular time period: they occur in many different places, to many different people, at many different times.

What are we to make of this? We must of course allow ample room for the possibility of ulterior motives in making such claims as well as for perfectly natural explanations for some of these experiences. It is, for example, undoubtedly true that some people simply fabricate angelic or demonic stories for attention, monetary gain or religious prestige—especially in our culture that in some quarters rewards individuals making such claims. Others who claim such experiences are without ques­tion psychologically or emotionally imbalanced. Still others may be sane enough and lack an ulterior motive but are simply mistaken in their interpretation of what they experienced. Perhaps they had a waking dream or a stress-related hallucination. In any event, such possibilities must certainly be critically considered as we examine each particular account provided by people who claim to have experienced a spiritual presence.

But surely it is unwarranted to assume that all such accounts can be explained away. If we take the time to examine these accounts we find that at least some of them are recounted by individuals whose motives are beyond reproach and whose psychological and emotional stability is beyond question. And many of them do not leave room for an easy natural explanation.

Since most of the world’s population throughout history has claimed to see something which certain western intellectuals are unable to see, perhaps it is the spiritual vision of secularized westerners that is faulty, not the perception of the rest of the world. Unless we arbitrarily and irrationally decide to dismiss all such accounts simply because they don’t conform to our presupposed ideas about things, such testimonies provide good evidence that spirits are real. At the very least, the evidence from history and from cultures outside the West should expose the arbitrariness and narrowness of those who simply assume that things like angels, demons and the Devil amount to nothing more than pieces of an ancient superstitious mindset.

Photo credit: Ramesh Vedula via Unsplash

Related Reading

Is Demon Possession Simply Psychological Catharsis?

Greg discusses demon possession and the believability of it. http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0151.mp3

The Warfare Worldview: What Would You Tell the Younger You?

Aftab Uzzaman via Compfight Jessica Kelley has been fleshing out the Warfare Worldview on her blog in a series of posts using the lens of the death of her child, Henry. Jessica is a beautiful writer, and her reflections are powerful and tender. You’re going to want to be listening to her. Her voice is an…

Did God Cause the Polar Vortex?

When is this polar vortex thing going to end? It’s March, and even in Minnesota we expect to see temperatures warmer than this. With all of the sleet and cold in the south, it seems like schools are closing more than they are open. While this is not a catastrophic event like a hurricane, tsunami,…

Why Did God Heal or Not?

In 1996 a 27-year-old man in my church named David was diagnosed with an inoperable brain cancer. The doctors decided to send David to the Mayo Clinic to receive some experimental treatments on the slim hope these might at least prolong his life. The night before David left, I and a dozen other people went…

Civilian or Soldier: Which Are You?

The Bible makes it clear that the people of God are to be on the offensive in storming the gates of hell (See post) and that Christians are to put on the armor of God (See post). However, in modern Western Christianity, it is much more common to behave more like civilians on a vacation than…

Who Needs to Pray and Fast? (podcast)

Greg puts a bow on our shortest episode ever.  Episode 634 http://traffic.libsyn.com/askgregboyd/Episode_0634.mp3